home
contents
psychcorner       
family matters
wellness  
this & that
diet & nutrition 
heal the world
spirituality
library
links
about us


 

submit articles  
to CrescentLife


ask the expert

Diagnosing Family Members

Question: 
My husband is a \"passive aggresive\" Frankenstein. He supliments this with greif, (the loss of a child), stress, (near  bankruptsey), sleeping problems, and several other personality disorders that I have yet to put my finger on. After 4 years of a marriage from hell I have only just discovered that most of our problems can be rounded up and classified under this name. 

My questions are, (I have set an appointment with a phsycotherapist), how long before we will start to see any changes, (months, years), how long will counselling need to go on typically, and is there anything that we can do at home in the meanwhile to begin to have a normal life?
Any ways to help him and to keep ourselves from going completely insane?

Response:
It is kind of dangerous to diagnose a person yourself. The behaviors you mention could also indicate depression or bipolar disorder. Scheduling an appointment with a psychotherapist is the first step to an accurate diagnosis. 

My suggestion at this point is to wait for the professional's diagnosis and suggestions. In my experience when a family member tries to be a therapist, it never works. (This does not mean that you are wrong in your understanding of what is going on with your husband, just that there could be many things you might be missing.) There are too many other
dynamics at play in your relationship for it to work. Patients are generally more open to 
hearing a diagnosis from a professional than a family member....which is often construed as criticism and lack of support. Instead, it would be more helpful if you note these problems and take them to the therapist... who with the whole picture in front can guide you better. 

Length of treatment depends on the diagnosis, the issues involved, the severity, intensity and duration of the problem and the willingness of the patient to work.... generally, some positive change should be noticeable within 6 months. 

I hope this helps
Regards
Uzma Mazhar